Buxom Big N Healthy Lip Polish in Shanghai (tingles, smells like mint, amazingly beautiful color, sheer but buildable, and I wear it very dark and have no problems with color payoff. You definitely need lipliner with that one.) Nars Velvet Matte Lip Pencil in Damned (more of a dark pinky red shade, it's a gorgeous color, but also can be a bit drying. Nars Pure Matte Lipstick in Terre de Feu (relatively not drying, for a matte formula. Lovely shade though, if that's what you're into)

Revlon Colorstay Ultimate Suede lipstick in Backstage (a bit drying, but then, it is a matte lipstick. Revlon Black Cherry (kind of a cult classic, really similar to the UD Shame, maybe a bit more reddish, and less opaque)

Urban Decay lipstick in Shame (another fave, not matte but gorgeous, I've found it to have awesome staying power as well, as long as you use lip liner!) Tarina Tarantino Lipstick in Florticulture Nars Scarlet Empress (my personal favorite, it's semi-matte and beautiful, such a nice shade, really great formula and staying power). Kat Von D Foiled Love Lipstick in FTW (not the nicest texture, I must admit. I'm a total fan! They look better on pale girls, in my opinion :) here are some of my faves Deep Burgundy Lipsticks on Pale Skin? | Beautylish

Purple lipsticks for fair skin